Ive tried liquid, pencil, every kind of eyeliner under the sun – and my all time favorite has got to be Mac Fluidline eyeliner. This little pot of gold will last you forever, and the consistency of the liner is so smooth and silky, you never pull on your lids when applying, like a pencil will do. And its softer then those liquid pens, although with the right brush, you can be just as precise.
My wedding makeup artist used this on my for my wedding, and I havent gone back since. A suprisingly good value at $15.00 at http://www.maccosmetics.com